Showing posts with label Women's Rights. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Women's Rights. Show all posts

Monday, December 24, 2012

An Extensive History of Wonder Woman, Supergirl, and Feminism

California State University student  Marina Hollon has published a thesis on the history of Wonder Woman and Supergirl and their objectification. From the thesis summary,

"This study argues that comic book publishers, editors, writers, artists, and fans imposed multiple limitations on Wonder Woman’s and Supergirl’s powers and independence. Although Wonder Woman and Supergirl embodied significant liberated characteristics: superpowers, independent lifestyles, higher education, white-collar careers, and financial independence, they were most limited by advertisements aimed at males and were also portrayed as unintelligent women, disempowered, and objectified. 
This study compares 242 of Wonder Woman’s and Supergirl’s comics from 1959 to 1984. The plots, images, and letter pages were analyzed in the context of Second Wave Feminism and the Cold War era. This study indicates a change over time from the superheroines’ portrayals of liberation to sexual objectification and the editor’s, writer’s, artist’s construction and fans’ reception of the women’s movement in comic book culture. The present study enhances existing scholarship in the fields of Women’s Studies, Media and Popular Culture Studies, and Sociology challenging popular cultural images of empowered superheroines. Although this study may seem of concern to only a small group of scholars and comic book fans, it should in fact concern anyone who cares about why gender inequity continues to exist. My original contribution shows how the influences of fans’ letters in Wonder Woman and Supergirl and the editors’ responses to the fans’ requests limited the superheroines’ liberated powers and behaviors by encouraging a sexualized style of superheroine art." 

The full 163 page thesis can be read here.

Saturday, December 8, 2012

io9 Roundup of Superhero, Political and Futurist Articles, Part 1

This weekend we've got a roundup of recent, relevant, and few just really cool, articles from the science, science fiction and fantasy blog io9.com. Stay tuned for all the parts.

Saturday, November 24, 2012

Wonder Woman! The Untold Story of American Superheroines

There's a new documentary in the works called "Wonder Woman! The Untold Story of American Superheroines" which talks about the history of Wonder Woman and the parallels of the feminist movement, and you can watch the trailer below.

Friday, November 16, 2012

A History of Female Superheroes

http://media.comicvine.com/uploads/6/67718/1627547-all_star_comics__8___page_72_super.jpg http://www.supermegamonkey.net/chronocomic/entries/scans2/MTIO32_InvisibleGirl.JPG http://images3.wikia.nocookie.net/__cb20080714203708/marveldatabase/images/3/33/Ms._Marvel_Vol_1_4.jpg Math

From the beginning of superhero comic book history, women were usually delegated to supporting roles, and were usually portrayed as either career women, romance-story heroines, or comedic teenagers.
This all began to change in the 1940s, as part of the growing women's empowerment of the time. The first known female superhero is Fantomah, a jungle woman with super natural powers, who debuted in Fiction House's Jungle Comics #2 on February 1940, made minor minor appearances in a few comic before disappearing, eventually lapsed into public domain and has since made several appearances in modern comics with the rediscovery of her first female superhero status, most recently in Hack/Slash. 1940 saw the arrival of several female superheros, including the original Black Widow, the first costume superheroine, Invisible Scarlet O'Neil, the first comic strip superheroine, and Nelvana of the Northern Lights, the first superheroine to headline a comic book. Femme fatales started becoming common archetypes. Wonder Woman, the most famous superheroine, soon made her debut in All Star Comics #8, published January 1942 and is frequently used as a feminist symbol, usually in a positive fashion.
Things changed in the 1950s with the implementation of the Comics Code, which placed certain restrictions on things like the portrayal of women in comics, like DC's In-house Editorial Policy of "The inclusion of females in stories is specifically discouraged. Women, when used in plot structure, should be secondary in importance, and should be drawn realistically, without exaggeration of feminine physical qualities". This resulted in women being relegated to supporting roles for some time, but writers began pushing against this by creating or reintroducing superheroine versions of popular superheroes, like Supergirl, Batwoman and Batgirl.
As the 50s changed into the 60s and second-wave feminism started, superheroines became more predominate, becoming equal (albeit gradually and often outnumbered) members of superteams, such as The Fantastic Four's Invisible Girl's developing the additional ability to generate force fields and transitioning from a damsel in distress to a confident second in command before changing her name to Invisible Woman and the increase in more prominent women on the X-Men. While at first often the "token female member", eventually they stated becoming the leaders of superteams, such as Storm becoming the leader of the X-Men. 1975 saw the reintroduction of the X-Men to the public after a five year hiatus, with the regular series Uncanny X-Men being written by Chris Claremont, whose 16 year run as the book's writer, in addition to other comics, was lauded for things like the creation of several strong female characters, including Shadowcat, and Mystique, and growing existing superheroines like Storm and Jean Grey. Claremont's depiction of smart, powerful, capable and multifaceted superheroines is credited for reinvigorated the portrayal of women in comic.
Feminism became a recurring subject in comic books, both positive, like the feminist solidarity symbol Ms. Marvel with her women's magazine editor day job and tagline "This Female Fights Back!", and negative, like the feminist "parody" supervillian Man-Killer. Superheroines saw a significant increase in their own titles, with some comic books like Spider-Girl becoming major sellers. The 90s saw an increase in more sexually open (and sexually explicit) comics as LGTB issues became story topics and underground and alternative comics grew in popularity with characters like Tank Girl. The rise of the internet allowed people to come together and re-examine past comics, and sites like Women in Refrigerators, which collected incidents of discrimination against women in comics and seek to analyze why these plot devices are used disproportionately on female characters, were created and incidents of women being portrayed as sexual objects are quickly reported and derided, such as the Mary Jane Laundry Statue or the recent Sexpot Starfire Controversy. Because of the attention these kinds of incidents have gathered depictions of women as stereotypes, sexual objects and victims of brutality has decreased in recent years.
Given that the audience for superhero comic books was primarily male until recently, female characters were designed to be targeted towards the male demographic. Despite the number of female superheroes created few have had significant stand alone success. It has long been debated if the perceived lack of female readership was due to male writers being uncomfortable or unable to write for or about women or if they are afraid that trying to appeal to women will lose them male interest. Some have said that women in general have a lack of interest in comics, but the rising number of women artists and writers, especially outside the superhero genre, suggests that's not the case. Whatever the reason, the growing trend of empowered and realistically portrayed women and superheroines is a positive sign for the industry, even if there are occasions where people in the industry lapse into misogynistic mindsets.

Thursday, November 15, 2012

Wonder Woman Cover Girl and Other Blips


 Wonder Woman is making an appearance on the cover of the 40th Anniversary Issue of Ms. Magazine in a cover similar to its first issue published in 1972 which also featured the superheroine, which you can read more about here.

Barack Obama will be making his first appearance as a second term president in a comic in Spawn #225, which we had previously mentioned would have a different story based upon who won the election. The issue will be released on November 21st, and you can read more about it here.

A new version of the Watchmen film has been released blending the "Ultimate Cut" with the original graphic novel. Director Zack Snyder has given an interview about the new version, the politics of Watchmen and the new Superman film he's directing, which you can read here.

Friday, September 21, 2012

Superheros, Equal Rights and Women's Health


And now, the superheroes shall comment on the candidates' equal rights and women's health platforms, and give a point for Obama, Romney or Undecided. Once again, some of these statements are direct or expanded quotes. Try to figure out which ones in the comments!



"Women have been very valuable to all of America, through their pluck and their heroism. Giving them and everyone else equal rights is something that should have been accomplished years ago."
Point for: Obama


"Women are being hard pressed on every side, but not crushed; persecuted, but not abandoned; struck down, but not destroyed. We must help them however we can, and voting for Obama will go a long way in helping."
Point for: Obama


"Wow. Romney is being really discriminator towards women and homosexuals. Is that even legal?"
Point for: Obama


Shadowcat
"Having been involved with so many fights for people's rights, and I can tell you Romney that people like you who would deny some people their rights are always on the losing side, especially if I have a say in the matter."
Point for: Obama



"If you have two people with the same skills fighting the same monster, you should be giving them the same pay. Obama sees fit to do that."
Point for: Obama


"Romney's attempt to distance himself from the issue shows that he knows his opinion isn't popular with the public, and for good reason."
Point for: Obama


Spider-Girl  
"Nobody should suffer because we failed to help when we should have. Obama is seeking to help as many as he can."
Point for: Obama


"A great man once said "Men are from Earth, Women are from Earth, Deal with It". I don't think Romney's dealing with it."
Point for: Obama


"President Obama is helping so many people. I want to help him help others."
Point for: Obama

"I've learned the hard way you can't go giving some people special treatment. You have to treat everyone equally, or things will go badly for everyone."
Point for: Obama
Mr. Incredible
"You can't go around denying people rights. Those people will be taken advantage of by others looking to exploit them. I'm glad Obama is fixing this."
Point for: Obama


"We need to be making the effort to reach out to the gay community with understanding and respect after many years of strife and heartbreak. Romney clearly doesn't want to do this."
Point for: Obama


"Obama's legal efforts to end inequality should be celebrated, not repealed."
Point for: Obama


"Discrimination in any form is wrong. People need to look past what's on the outside and see people for who they really are. Romney has basically said he doesn't want to do that."
Point for: Obama


Linda Park-West
"Romney doesn't want to talk about these issues? Then I don't want to talk about him."
Point for: Obama



The Savage Dragon
"Abolishing hate crime task forces and cutting funding to hate crime prevention is a sure way to increase crime. If Romney did that to the whole country, there would be trouble, and I'd bring it right to him."
Point for: Obama


"I don't think Romney knows about all of the services Planned Parenthood provides, and how crucial it is for some people. His ignorance is really starting to show."
Point for: Obama


"Romney's actions are straight up discrimination. One bad lab accident and he could be a supervillian!"
Point for: Obama.


"Would we be having this discussion if we replaced 'women' or 'gay people' with 'blacks'? So then why does Romney want to keep denying people the same rights?"
Point for: Obama


"Helping people shouldn't be about where they were born, who they are or what they wear. It's about what you do, It's about the actions you take. And I think Romney's taking the wrong actions."
Point for: Obama





Conclusion



Issue Obama/Biden Undecided Romney/Ryan
Economy
19
1
0
Energy & Environment
19
1
0
Healthcare
20
0
0
Education
20
0
0
Equal Rights and Women's Health
20
0
0

I don't think anyone is surprised with this one. Romney's refusal to talk about the subject really hurts him. Do any of you agree with the superheroes' comments? If you think any of the heroes have been misrepresented, let me know in the comments!

Tomorrow I'll have an article on Captain America's new position, Sunday with some insight into presidential minds, and then on Monday I'll have a piece on Utilitarianism. If you have any suggests, feel free to post them in the comments.
~James


Wednesday, September 19, 2012

Equal Rights and Women's Health Platforms


For this week's issue, we'll look at candidates' platforms on Equal Rights and Women's Health. Once again, all information and videos are taken directly from the candidates' websites, either in part or in whole, unless otherwise noted, with minimal alteration to clarify and streamline information.

Barack Obama
Summarized from Obama's Website

  • President Obama signed the Lilly Ledbetter Fair Pay Act to help women fight back against pay discrimination. He understands that when women are paid less than men for the same work, it hurts the entire family.
  • President Obama was the first sitting president to publicly announce his support for marriage for same-sex couples, and has always believed LGBT Americans should be treated fairly and equally
  • President Obama repealed “Don’t Ask, Don’t Tell,” so that gay and lesbian service members no longer have to lie about who they are to serve the country they love.
  • President Obama endorsed the Respect for Marriage Act, signed the Matthew Shepard and James Byrd, Jr. Hate Crimes Prevention Act, and extended hospital visitation and medical decision-making rights to LGBT couples. 
  • President Obama has enacted policies that promote the hiring of people with disabilities, increased funding for students with disabilities, provide Americans with access to affordable health care, and improve accessibility standards.
  • President Obama is putting an end to the health insurance company practice of charging women more than men for the same coverage.
  • Thanks to Obamacare, many insurance plans are beginning to fully cover birth control without co-pays or deductibles as part of women's preventive care—potentially saving women hundreds of dollars every year.
  • President Obama believes a woman’s health care choices are personal decisions, best made with her doctor—without interference from politicians.
  • President Obama fought back against Republican attempts to defund Planned Parenthood, one of the largest providers of women’s health services, including breast and cervical cancer screenings, and birth control. Under Obamacare, health insurance companies now cover recommended preventive care like mammograms and cancer screenings, and are beginning to cover birth control without co-pays or deductibles.


Romney's Rebuttal


Romney offers no rebuttal to Obama's Equal Rights or Women's Health platforms on his website, so here an small interview by Romney from May, 2012 for as close a rebuttal by Romney on Obama's Equal Rights Platform I could find. I couldn't not find anything from Romney specifically addressing Obama's Women's Health platform, so if anyone knows of anything let me know and I'll update this article.

Mitt Romney
Romney offers no opinion about Equal Rights or Women's Health on his website, so here are some videos of Mitt Romney on the subjects. Apologies for the lack of straight up Romney-only debates
 speech, his lack of any official releases makes that difficult to do, but his position should still be made clear.

Visit NBCNews.com for breaking news, world news, and news about the economy

Visit NBCNews.com for breaking news, world news, and news about the economy


Obama's Rebuttal (Summarized from Obama's Website)

  • Mitt Romney refused to say whether or not he would have signed the Lilly Ledbetter Fair Pay Act into law. 
  • Mitt Romney would enshrine discrimination into the Constitution with an amendment to ban marriage for same-sex couples.
  • Mitt Romney refused to support the repeal of “Don’t Ask, Don’t Tell,” and would have left the policy in place.
  • As governor, Mitt Romney cut funding for hate crimes prevention and abolished a hate crimes task force.
  • Mitt Romney would repeal the Affordable Care Act and slash Medicaid, which many Americans with disabilities rely on.
  • Mitt Romney would let employers, insurance companies, and politicians limit women’s health choices.
  • Mitt Romney would repeal Obamacare, and give employers the authority to limit women’s access to common forms of birth control.
  • Mitt Romney believes that Roe v. Wade should be overturned, and backed an extreme proposal to outlaw abortions even in the case of incest and rape.
  • Mitt Romney would eliminate all federal funding for Planned Parenthood, and roll back all the benefits of health reform.

Conclusion
So in summary, Obama has been giving women more rights, in both the work place and with their medical needs and equal rights for LGTB people, while Romney literally supports making discrimination against women and LGTB people legal. That kinda sickens me...

Turn in Friday for the Superhero opinions. I don't think there will be any question which way the heroes side on this one though...
~James